Top of page
SponsorUS Water Systems
LA Dodger Talk

Two Former Can't-Miss Prospects. One Trade. Who Gets the Last Laugh?

Andrew Friedman acquired a former No. 1 overall draft pick who once looked destined for superstardom. In exchange, he surrendered a former first-round pitcher who once looked destined to anchor the Dodgers' rotation, plus a promising young catcher.

By Mark Timmons5 min readJump to 25 comments

Well, it will take at least a couple of years to decide who laughs last, but I like this trade for the Dodgers; however, it's a gamble on yesterday's talent becoming tomorrow's production.

Andrew Friedman acquired a former No. 1 overall draft pick who once looked destined for superstardom. In exchange, he surrendered a former first-round pitcher who once looked destined to anchor the Dodgers' rotation, plus a promising young catcher. Neither Lewis nor Miller has fulfilled their considerable potential. Both are 27 years old.

That's what makes this deal so interesting. It's a change-of-scenery trade involving two players whose greatest accomplishments might still be ahead of them. Don't forget that the Dodgers have been known to take underachievers and turn them into stars...The Dodgers also addressed a specific need: a right-handed infielder following Miguel Rojas' retirement.

1. Royce Lewis: Superstar potential or damaged goods?

Lewis Stats

Lewis once hit 15 home runs in just 58 games. In 2026, he required 125 games to hit the same number. But there's another side to the story: Lewis has experienced two ACL tears in the same knee, along with hamstring, quadriceps, oblique, and adductor issues. Despite those injuries, he played a career-high 125 games in 2026. The talent hasn't necessarily disappeared, but the production certainly has.

The most interesting statistic: Lewis against left-handed pitching

LHP S

This may be the most important part of the deal. Lewis has a career 108 wRC+ against left-handed pitchers, meaning his offense has been approximately 8% better than league average in those matchups, adjusted for park effects.

The Dodgers don't necessarily need a 600-plate-appearance version of Royce Lewis. They need someone who can punish left-handed pitching while giving Freddie Freeman and Max Muncy occasional rest. I see Lewis playing 3B against LHP, but maybe that's not what the Dodgers see... More about that later.

And here's an interesting nugget: Lewis ranked in the 86th percentile in bat speed in 2026. The raw physical ability is still there!

Bobby Miller: What happened to the future ace?

Bobby Ace

In 2023, Miller went 11-4 with a 3.76 ERA and 119 strikeouts over 124⅓ innings. He looked like a legitimate fixture in the future rotation. But since then:

  • Shoulder problems and other injuries interrupted his development.

  • His 2024 performance deteriorated dramatically.

  • He pitched only 12⅓ major-league innings combined in 2025 and 2026.

  • He had a 5.71 ERA over 17⅓ Triple-A innings in the second half of 2026.

The Dodgers have plenty of pitching options, and Miller had fallen well down the organizational depth chart. Here's the question for LADT readers: Did the Dodgers give up on Bobby Miller too soon, or did they recognize that his window of opportunity in Los Angeles was closing?

I suspect Friedman made a calculated decision that Miller's value to the Dodgers had become considerably smaller than his theoretical upside.

Don't overlook Francisco Espinoza

The third player in this trade is 19-year-old catcher/first baseman Francisco Espinoza.

His combined 2026 minor-league numbers:

  • .317 batting average

  • .411 OBP

  • .422 slugging

  • 46 games between the complex league and Single-A

Baseball America reports that Espinoza has some encouraging plate discipline and power indicators, but questions his future behind the plate. His 57.1% groundball rate is also a concern. Espinoza is a legitimate young prospect, but he's far from a sure thing.

Minnesota is buying upside in two players. Los Angeles is buying a more immediate major-league fit.

What does this mean for Alex Freeland?

Lewis played 82 games at first base, 40 at third base and 16 at second base in 2026. His defensive value and versatility are not the same as Miguel Rojas' were, particularly at shortstop. If Lewis is penciled in as the primary second baseman, what happens to Alex Freeland?

My preference would be to give Freeland a legitimate opportunity to win the job rather than automatically awarding it to Lewis. Lewis can provide right-handed offense, infield depth, and potentially a platoon option at 3B and 1B (occasionally). That doesn't mean Freeland should sit.

In fact, this trade makes more sense to me if Lewis is a complementary player rather than a guaranteed everyday starter.

$$$$$$$

Lewis is projected to earn approximately $5.1 million through arbitration for 2027 and remains under team control through 2028, with free agency expected after that season. That gives the Dodgers two seasons to see whether they can restore something resembling his 2023 production.

At that projected salary, it's a relatively modest financial gamble for Los Angeles, although the opportunity cost includes Miller and Espinoza.

My Trade Grades

The Dodgers fill a need without giving up a pitcher who was central to their current plans. The significant upside makes this worthwhile. Minnesota gets a potential power arm and a promising young hitter for a player who had been considered a possible non-tender candidate.

Here are the Questions:

  1. If the Dodgers couldn't fix Bobby Miller, why should we assume Minnesota can?

  2. Was Lewis' 2023 breakout a glimpse of his true ability, or simply a spectacular 58-game hot streak?

  3. Is Lewis really an upgrade over the players the Dodgers already have at second base?

  4. Could Lewis become the heir apparent to Max Muncy at third base, or even provide insurance for Freeman at first?

  5. Will we regret including Francisco Espinoza in this trade five years from now?

The Dodgers traded a former can't-miss pitcher for a former can't-miss hitter. Bobby Miller had the arm of an ace, while Royce Lewis once had the bat of a future All-Star. Neither has delivered on those expectations. But there is one significant difference: Lewis still fills an immediate need on this Dodgers roster, while Miller had become an afterthought in their pitching plans. At 27, neither player is old, and both have plenty of time to resurrect their careers. I have no problem trading a pitcher the Dodgers weren't using for a hitter who might help them win another championship. But if Royce Lewis hits .227 again, don't expect me to call Andrew Friedman a genius. The Dodgers didn't acquire the Royce Lewis in 2023. They acquired the Royce Lewis of 2026, hoping their development staff can bring the former back to life.

Discussion (25)

Disagree, not disagreeable

Tips: paste a YouTube, X link on its own line to embed it. Use **bold**, *italic*, > quote, or - list for formatting.

How to post a photo
  • Click 📷 Add a photo, pick the picture, wait for ✓ Ready, then click Post comment. You can also paste a copied picture into the comment box.
  • Your photo is resized and its hidden details (like the location it was taken) are removed before it leaves your device. It only shows once your comment is live.
  • Already have a picture online? Paste its address (ending in .jpg, .png, .webp or .gif) on its own line instead.
  • Up to 3 photos show per comment, and a first-time commenter's photos and links are reviewed before they appear.

Be civil — moderation is real. Links may need a moment of review. By posting you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy. Your email is never shown.

  1. Dodgerdad

    You da man Bear!!

  2. Dodgerdad

    Once a person has determined that they are far superior to others, why bother participating in trivial conversation with those said. Lesser individuals?

  3. Michael "Bear" Norris

    MLB is flooding TV and the internet with ads about how the fans want a cap and a floor. Manfred is adamant that MLB is trying to accommodate the fans wishes. Seems to me like he is downplaying the owners of small market teams who would benefit the most from a cap yet finally be forced to spend some cash.

  4. Michael "Bear" Norris

    I like the trade, low risk type of move often made by AF. Is Teo the next on the list? What could they get for him? He is more of a DH now than an everyday outfielder.

  5. Bobby

    Royce Lewis has proved over his entire career that he's not capable of being consistently healthy. So it's a little silly to assume he'll now come LA, where nobody is ever healthy all year, and become the next Cal Ripken Ironman and take over 2b, and eventually take over 3b or whatever else.

    He's best in a platoon, playing 4x a week to rest whatever issues his body has. He should be used as such. His acquisition by no means 2b is settled.

    If the Mets rumored offer to Skubal is near 400mil, I don't think we will keep him. And as much as I want to keep him, perhaps that's not the worst thing, as we do have some top prospects to deal for an impact starting pitcher should we need one.

    Now, it's time for some college football starting at 9am! Let's see if UCLA can keep this crazy season going.

  6. Bluto

    This is dreadful writing.

  7. dodgerpatchEdited

    Lewis isn't a great defensive player, and his double blown out knee has likely reduced his range and quickness. I don't see him as a replacement for Rojas. Freeland will never be a starter. He's a good glove with good makeup, but a below average bat with strikeout issues. He's more likely to be the Miggy Ro replacement IMO. If Lewis can play an OK first, he could be valuable as a workload manager for Freddie and Muncy. If a miracle happens and he fulfills his potential, he could be potential replacement for Muncy in a couple of years, but then he'll be pushing 30 and a FA, so bit of a longshot.

  8. LionelsmirkEdited

    Miller is no longer a power pitcher. He's a breaking ball heavy reliever who could carve out a nice career in that roll.

    I like the gamble, though worry about Espinoza coming back to bite us.

    I think Lewis creates options. Even as a multi-position infield starter he provides value. If he's healthy and jibes with Mookie up the middle, we could have our 2B settled.

  9. Andrew V ForteEdited

    I like the trade. Lewis has potential if he stays healthy. Miller needed a change of scenery in a place where there is less pressure and with the Twins, he might thrive. With Call signed, there is NOT much room on the bench for both Kim and Freeland unless there is an upcoming trade.