Diminutive sluggers: Players 6 foot or shorter

There are players of all shapes and sizes in baseball. Size does not really matter. In today's game, things are somewhat different, teams will shy away from shorter pitchers in search of the pitcher who can throw 100 plus or at least in the high 90's consistently.
Hitters are a bit harder to judge. Teams would love the complete package in a hitter, power and contact. That doesn't always happen. But some players you look at and just know they can hit the ball a long way. I remember the first time I ever saw Frank Howard up close. He was huge. 6'7", around 260. The ball just sounded different coming off of his bat, Ted Kluzewski was another. Massive arms that looked even bigger because he wore those cut off jerseys with no sleeves. Aaron Judge and Ohtani project that today.

Some sluggers though, have been not so intimidating. Many great power hitters have been six foot tall or shorter. Some may have seemed taller to us as fans. Yet the record for the most runs driven in during a season is held by an outfielder who was 5'6" and weighed 190 pounds. He even played for Brooklyn for parts of 3-seasons when he was past his prime. He would be out of the game at age 34, his name, Lewis Robert Wilson, better known as Hack. Wilson debuted with the New York Giants and spent part of 3 seasons in New York. He did ok but did not impress the Giants so they traded him to Toledo in the American Association. Just before the 1926 season, the Cubs purchased him from Toledo. He hit .321/21/109 with his 21 homers the most in the NL. He also led the league in walks with 69. He struck out just 61 times. Wilson would lead the NL in homers four times between 26-30. In his six years in Chicago, he hit .322/190/768 and his OPS was 1.002. In 1930, Wilson hit .356/56/191. He did not win the triple crown because Bill Terry hit .401. Wilson's .356 was 10th. But his 191 RBIs were a record. Lou Gehrig's 185 in 31, and Greenburg's 184 in 37, are the only other totals above 180. Wilson's career headed downhill after that. He was a heavy drinker, and the Cubs owner expressed a desire to trade him. hack hit .280/38/204 with Brooklyn. He died at age 48 in 1948. His original RBI count was 190, but in 1999 the baseball commissioner added a run that had been wrongly credited to Charlie Grimm. Hack was elected to the hall by the Veterans committee in 1979.

Joe Morgan was 5'7" tall. During his 10 seasons with the Astros, he hit just 72 homers. In 8 years with the Reds, he doubled that total with 152. He was not a great power hitter per-se, the most he ever hit was 27. But he could beat you many ways, and home runs were on of his weapons. He would hit 268 in his long career. He won back-to-back MVP award with the Reds in 74-75 as part of the Big Red Machine. His 11.0 WAR led the league in 75. Four times in his career, his WAR was over 9. He did pretty well against LA with 29 homers and 105 driven in. He was elected to the Hall in 1990. Joe passed away at age 77 in October of 2020.

To look at the next player, you would not even take him for a professional baseball player. In his career he hit 358 homers, and in the 50's, he hit more homers than Mays, Banks and Williams, and he never led the league in homers his entire career. 11 times he hit more than 20. He also has 3 MVP awards to his credit and 10 World Series rings. If you haven't figured who it is yet, it is Yogi Berra. Yogi was known for his humorous takes sometimes, like when he once said, nobody goes to that restaurant anymore, it's too crowded! But the guy could hit. He was lifelong friends with Hall of Fame announcer, Joe Garagiola, they lived on the same street in St. Louis. Besides his 358 bombs in the regular season, Yogi hit 12 in World Series play. He also managed the Mets and the Yankees, winning a pennant with each. Yogi passed away in September of 2015; he was 90 years old. Elected to the Hall in 1972.

The Dodgers have had a couple of players like this. Steve Garvey, Ron Cey and Jimmy Wynn were all just 5'10". All three slugged more than 250 homers, Cey 316, Wynn 291, Garvey 272. All were prominent members of the 1974 pennant winner. The Dodgers though, have a slugger who is shorter, and not as stockily built. Mooke Betts is 5'9, 180 pounds. At this point in his career, he has slugged 314 homers. 175 of those as a Dodger. If he matches his 162 game average this year, he will go over 200 in LA. His lowest total in LA was 16 in the pandemic season. He hit 19 in 2024 when he missed significant time with a broken hand. Mookie has six seasons left on his contract. He will pass Cey on the All-time LA list soon, He should pass Piazza 177, Furillo 192 and Kemp 203 next year.

Perhaps the greatest slugger in New York Giants history, Mel Ott stood just 5'9" tall and he weighed 170 pounds. Not the kind of body you would expect to hit 511 homers. He led the NL six times and never hit more than 38 in a season. Even more amazing is the fact that he played a majority of his games in the old Polo Grounds and he hit 323 of his dingers there. He also hit a majority of his homers, 177, with 2 outs. He hit .301 with 71 homers and 244 RBIs against Brooklyn. Elected to the Hall in 1951, he was just 49 when he died in 1958.

The next player is not very popular among Dodger fans for good reason, but at 5'6" 167 pounds, he generates a lot of power with his bat. Jose Altuve has hit 271 homers over his 16-year career with Houston. He has hit 20 or more homers seven times in his career. His high is 31, which he has achieved twice. Here is the kicker, he is second on the All-Time postseason home run list with 28. One behind slugger Manny Ramirez and 4 in front of Kyle Schwarber. Max Muncy is tied for 7th on the list with 19 with Seager and Pujols. If Houston returns to the playoffs next season, Altuve, who has 3 years remaining on his contract could easily tie and pass Ramirez. Altuve, like Morgan, added speed to his game also. He led the AL in stolen bases twice and has 330 in his career.

He is perhaps the greatest switch-hitter in baseball history. His only contemporary in my mind is Eddie Murray. At 5'11" tall, 195 pounds he generated power from both sides of the plate. He clubbed 536 homers in his 18-year career. The "Commerce Comet", Mickey Mantle was a true 5-tool player. Injuries and a somewhat self-destructive lifestyle kept him from bigger numbers. He won the triple crown in 1956, 3 MVP awards, led the league in homers 4 times and teamed with Roger Maris in 1961 to hit 115 homers as teammates. A major league record and 8 more than Ruth and Gehrig hit in 1927. Only other teammates with 100, Alex Rodriguez and Rafael Palmerio. Oddly, he drove in 100 or more runs just four times and never played a full season of games. He hit 18 home runs in World Series play. The Mick played on 7 World Championship teams, and in 12 World Series. He passed away at age 63 in 1995. He was elected to the Hall in 1974.

He antagonized the Dodgers for years. He was to many, the greatest Giant of them all. He was to me the best all-around player I had ever seen. He was the "Sey-Hey Kid", Willie Mays. Mays was 5'10" 170 pounds. He had speed and power. A cannon for an arm, and he hit for average. Willie would hit 660 homers in his career. When he retired, he was 2nd only to Babe Ruth. Now he is #6. He led the NL in homers four times, the last time with 52 in 1965. Unlike some of his peers, Willie only played in 3 World Series and had just 1 homer. He won the MVP award twice and finished in the top 10 in voting 10 times. 20 All-Star games, Rookie of the Year, 12 Gold Gloves all won consecutively, now you know why Willie Davis never got one. Elected to the Hall in 1979 and passed away at age 93 in 2024.

Kirby Puckett was 5'8", 178 pounds. He was powerfully built. He would play just 12 seasons in the majors, his career cut short by glaucoma. He finished his career with 207 homers, and two World Series championships. He was an All-Star 10 times with 6 gold gloves and 7 silver slugger awards. He finished in the top 10 in MVP voting 7 times. He was a .318 career hitter and led the league in hits 4 times. He won the 89-batting title with a .339 BA and hit over .300 eight times in his career. He hit .309/5/16 in 4 postseason series and was the MVP of the 1991 LCS. In 1996, Puckett was tearing up the Grapefruit League with a .344 BA. He woke up on Match 28th with no vision in his right eye. He got the glaucoma diagnosis and went on the DL for the first time in his career. He had three surgeries over the next few months and no success restoring vision to his right eye. He then got the diagnosis of central retina vein occlusion. It was apparent that he would never play again. He announced his retirement and the Twins hired him as executive vice president. He earned the 1996 Roberto Clemente award for community service. His # 34 was retired by the Twins in 1997 and he was elected to the Hall of Fame in 2001. On March 6th, 2006, he suffered a massive hemorrhagic stroke. He was taken to the emergency room and had surgery to relieve the pressure. It was unsuccessful and his Twins teammates were informed of his death the next day. Puckett at 45 was the second youngest Hall of Famer to die after being inducted while living, the youngest was Lou Gehrig.

There were several sluggers who were just 6 feet tall. Duke Snider, Aaron, Musial, Reggie Jackson, Jimmy Foxx, Maris, Banks, Norm Cash, Graig Nettles, Bagwell, Ron Gant, Greg Vaughn, Ron Santo and George Brett. Ivan Rodriguez was 5'9", Ricky Henderson was 5'11" as was Biggio and Rogers Hornsby. Ozzie Albies, the Braves second baseman is just 5'7" and has hit 30 homers twice. He averages 24 bombs a year. Muncy is 5'10", he has hit 35 or more 4 times in his career. He averages 34 over a 162-game schedule. And then there was Campanella. The three-time MVP was just 5'9", slightly taller than Yogi. Had he been allowed to play before he was 26, he would most likely have hit 300 plus homers in the majors. He finished with 242 in his 10-year-career. That puts him 4th on the Dodgers all-time list. It also means that Muncy is just 4 homers away from tying him. Max needs 32 more to tie him with Karros for 3rd on the all-time list.

Discussion (13)
Disagree, not disagreeable
This was fun to research. Some very good pitchers have been pretty short too. Bobby Shantz, who won the 1952 AL MVP award while with the A's, he had a 24-7 record that year, was just 5'6" 139 pounds. Roy Face, who famously threw a forkball and was 18-1 in 1959, was 5'8" 155.
With respect to Dustin May’s 3-year $52.5MM contract with CWS, good for him. But this sure feels like a reach. Three years and never being considered a qualified starter (162.0 IP)? Needs to average 2.2 fWAR. He has reached that once, last year. He is going to need to earn 6.6 fWAR over the contract. In his 7 years he has compiled a total of 7.0 fWAR. His K:BB is just 2.71. What does that mean for Freddy Peralta, Michael King, or Trevor Rogers.
Alex Vesia saw what Evan Phillips signed for. Vesia is 17 months younger than Phillips, suffered only short-term stints on the IL, with no surgeries. Since he entered MLB, Vesia has only 42 days on the IL with 25 coming in 2020 with Covid. Vesia’s career ERA, WHIP, ERA+, and K% are all superior to Phillips’. Vesia also walks more and has a slightly more HR%. Phillips has more experience closing games, but only has 2 the last two years compared to Vesia’s 8. Vesia wants to be a Dodger, but he is not Max Muncy. This is Vesia’s chance at a payday. If Phillips and May deserve 3 years, so does Vesia. Will the Dodgers give him three?
Per Robert Murray and Rosenthal:
Free-agent RHP Dustin May in agreement with White Sox on three-year, $52.5M contract.
Small in stature ? It’s a different sport, but how about Mugsy Bogues? 5’3 in the NBA? Averaged around 8 points and 7 assists for his career! Spud Webb? Won a dunk contest! You don’t have to be 6’5 to be a star! It’s funny how you think some of our favorites are always bigger than life, and that they are shorter than most. I always thought Bruce Springsteen was around 6’3 . Turns out he is only about 5’9- 5’10! Mookie may be only 5’9, but he sure has played bigger his entire career! I guess being short isn’t a bad thing! Being 7 foot tall and bad at basketball? Now that’s sad!